wook77: (yoda idiot)
wook77 ([personal profile] wook77) wrote2006-08-14 10:15 am

Help with canon

Ok, so this is what goes through my head as I'm trying to sleep... (yes, Yoda is talking to me)


Wook's canon question(s) of the moment -


Voldemort split his soul into a proposed 7 Horcruxes. Then he was "killed" by Harry.

When he was "killed", does that mean he used one of the Horcruxes so that there were only 6 for Harry and Dumbledore to destroy?

If he didn't, then how did he survive? Shouldn't his soul have been so weakened from being split up like that that he couldn't have survived without using one of his Horcruxes?

If he did, which one did he use?

Am I just being a moron because there's an obvious answer somewhere in the books that I didn't see? Has this been debated a gadzillion times and I just didn't pay attention?

Thoughts? Feelings? Suggestions? Links to previous discussions?

[identity profile] eviljade.livejournal.com 2006-08-14 05:55 pm (UTC)(link)
Wow. You beat me to posting by a couple of minutes but that is very close to my response. Here I was thinking I must be the only one who was looking at it that way and you go and post nearly the same theory.

Very cool. :)
ext_14568: Lisa just seems like a perfectly nice, educated, middle class woman...who writes homoerotic fanfiction about wizards (Default)

[identity profile] midnitemaraud-r.livejournal.com 2006-08-14 06:13 pm (UTC)(link)
Yay! *g*

(Not that my reply to Wook was all that articulate - I repeated myself a couple of times. :) It's easier with diagrams and pie charts!)

[identity profile] eviljade.livejournal.com 2006-08-14 06:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Seemed clear to me. Not repetitious at all.

Of course, that could be because I agreed with everything you said. *g*